 |
Failures
of Our Fathers - Part I
The
Constitution of the United States is the central
document of our nation, and one of the most important
documents ever written by man. It lays out principles
and basic operations of our nation and the government.
It has served as a model for many nations around the
globe. It has endured for over two centuries.
I
will now most humbly attempt to take a look at where the
United States is today vis-à-vis The
Constitution, and point out some areas where The
Constitution was lacking or unclear that have over
the course of two centuries taken us off the path the
Founding Fathers designed.
This
will be a continuing series of essays, each covering one
topic. This is the first.
The Constitution envisioned a nation consisting of
three components, a Citizenry, the Federal
Government, and State governments. Little is said
about the primacies of these entities vis-à-vis one and
other. There are smatterings throughout the
Constitution, such as the Bill of Rights, the
statement that if a power is not mentioned than the
Federal Government does not have that power and it
is reserved for the states, etc.
I
think the original intent was to establish a primacy
with the Citizenry on top, the Federal Government
next, but with a limited range of power, and then the
state governments with essentially unlimited power
except in areas reserved for the Federal government, and
subject to the primacy of the citizenry. Over
the course of 200 years, we have evolved into an
environment where the Federal Government has
primacy overall, flowed by the states and then
the citizenry. The Federal Government through is
taxation and spending power dictates to states how
things will be. Does anyone think that the founders
intended a Federal Government that set speed
limits on roadways or dictated the education of our
children? Not in least.
As
far as the citizenry is concerned the Federal
Government decides what rights it will bestow on the
citizens today and what rights it will take away. The
citizens have no right to free speech (even political
speech). The Federal Government determines what
can or can not be said, when and where it can or can not
be said, and who can or can not say it (campaign
finance reform). In turn the Federal
Government can create a right and bestow it upon the
populace (at least some of the populace) out of thin
air….the right to privacy. Whether or not I
think there should be one, there is not one mentioned in
The Constitution.
So,
failure number one, the need to establish the
citizenry as the primary element of the nation, to be
served by two co-equal layers of government with
specific, limited and unexpandable powers granted to
each. The latter being required to insure
the former.
|
 |